As the leaves begin to fall and the nights grow longer, we all know that spooky season is upon us. It’s that magical time of year when pumpkins light up our doorsteps, costumes come to life, and eerie tales are whispered around campfires. But what’s a Halloween gathering without a spine-tingling concoction to set the mood? In this recipe roundup, we’re diving into the world of scary Halloween punch, where creepy ingredients and creative presentation combine to make your party a hauntingly good time. These 21 Terrifying Halloween Punch Recipes are sure to get you and your guests right into the spooky vibes needed for a fantastic costume party.

Scary halloween punch with red hand print in orange punch
Want to save this recipe?
Just enter your email and get it sent to your inbox! Plus you’ll get new recipes from us every week!
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

We’ve got a range from eyeball punch to fizzy witches’ brews to ghoulish drinks for the kids. Whether you need a strong cocktail to get through the frights of the night or a virgin version for the little ones, we’ve got the recipes you need. Get ready to brew up some spooky fun! 

1. Four Ingredient Halloween Punch

Let’s start off with something simple and easy to make. This terrifying Halloween punch is just four ingredients, but is a spooky green color. It also can be eerily smoky from the top which is perfect for scaring your guests. It’s festive, fruity, and spiked which is just what we want for a spooky night. 

2. Terrifying Halloween Punch: Witch’s Brew

We absolutely have to bring the witches into this. October is witchy territory, and we celebrate that with this delicious witch’s brew. This terrifying Halloween punch is a tangy mix of ginger ale, pineapple juice, fresh lemon juice, and lime sherbet. It is a gorgeous green color and grosses out kids and adults.

3. Sparkling Cranberry Orange Eyeball Punch

It may be hard to decide between disgusting or terrifying with this one. Either way, it works great for a Halloween party. A lychee stuffed with a blueberry makes a terrific eyeball for this punch, and it adds flavor. The flavor – cranberry orange- goes perfectly with the season too. It’s a must make! 

4. Easy Terrifying Halloween Punch

This Halloween punch is simple and classic. A fizzy lemon lime soda is combined with a sweet orange sherbet to give you a delicious, creamy punch. With decor such as Trolli edible eyeballs or some sour gummy worms, you can easier than ever have a spooky Halloween party perfect for kids. 

5. Fizzy Purple Potion

This kid-friendly Halloween drink would be perfect to sip while trick or treating or after while sorting through your candy stash. It’s also awesome for a party and can be transformed into a punch bowl recipe. The purple color is perfect for Halloween – it’s a terrifying color to drink!

6. Terrifying Halloween Punch: Vampire Style

Similar to witches, Halloween isn’t Halloween without a vampire. And what better way to make a terrifying Halloween punch than with some vampire fangs and blood decor. Dracula himself would be jealous of this punch recipe. It’s simple to make with just some strawberry soda, cranberry juice, rumchata, and a bit of red food coloring. 

7. Terrifying Halloween Punch: Werewolf Style 

If you’re looking for a fun kid-friendly punch for your Halloween party, this Werewolf Punch is it! It’s made with fruit punch, lemon-lime soda, and pineapple juice. This Halloween punch recipe is super simple to whip up and will serve about 24 people so it’s great for a large party. With some eyeballs and coconut shavings, it’s sure to terrify its partakers. 

8. Halloween Party Slime Eyeball Punch

This terrifying Halloween punch is a fun take on boba drinks. Black boba is put to use in this green drink to freak you out. Although it’s delicious, it is eerie to look at. Green Berry Rush Hawaiian punch is mixed with ginger ale to create a fizzy, yummy drink with a great color.  

9. The Best Spooky Halloween Punch

Spooky Halloween punch is delicious and it makes a large batch. The recipe goes over how to make ice hands that sit in the punch to keep it cool, but also to add that terrifying aspect. It’s a fun way to get creative and wow your guests. A bit of dry ice gives it the smoky effect we love. 

10. Gespenstischbowle (Spooky Punch)

This German spooky punch packs a punch! It’s full of vodka, schnapps, champagne, and rum. It’s no joke. While it does contain a good bit of booze, it doesn’t have that boozy flavor, which can be a good thing or a bad thing depending on your drinking style. This punch is sure to get the spooky party started! 

11. Terrifying Halloween Punch with Orange Sherbert and 7UP

The combination of eyeballs, orange liquid, and green lime slices give this punch a really spooky look. The orange sherbert gives it a nice cool, sweet flavor, while the 7UP keeps it light and fizzy. You can easily spike it if you’re serving adults, or keep it non-alcoholic. It’s delicious either way. 

12. Zombie Brains Halloween Cocktail

Halloween month is here, and this spooky Zombie Brains Halloween Cocktail will have you feeling the Halloween spirit in no time. To make this Zombie Brains Halloween cocktail, mix vodka, Chambord, pomegranate juice, freshly squeezed orange juice, raspberries, and ginger ale. Muddle raspberries in a cocktail shaker to give the cocktail plenty of fresh raspberry flavor and turn them into a juicier consistency.

13. Worm Infested Goblin’s Blood

Just the name is terrifying! But don’t worry, everyone will drink this punch right up. You need just five ingredients for this Halloween drink. Punch packets, sugar, orange juice, and Sprite make up the actual drink. Frozen gummy worms are added for Halloween decor, to keep it cool, and to add to the fun! 

14. Black Widow Venom

Probably the most terrifying drink on this list, we’re talking about a black widow venom Halloween cocktail. There’s an adult version as well as a kid version, but either way, it’s freaky and absolutely terrifying. I’m going to be honest, I don’t know if I could drink this even though I know the spiders are plastic. But that’s the point of Halloween!

15. Polyjuice Potion Punch

This Polyjuice Potion recipe is a non-alcoholic drink that has just 4 basic ingredients and can be dressed up with whatever you like, including spiders, eyeballs, or other creepy crawly creatures. It’s so easy, it’s truly transformative. The cranberry apple juice gives it the fall flavors we love. It’ll be a hit at any party. 

16. Spooky Fog Drinks

This spooky fog drink is perfect for a kid’s Halloween party. It’s slightly eerie with the fog topping the drink, but not so much that they won’t drink it. You can make these into a variety of colors, or keep it spooky green. It’s easy to make which is exactly what you need when hosting a kid’s party. 

17. Terrifying Halloween Punch: Oogie Boogie Punch 

You’re joking, you’re joking, I can’t believe my eyes! This Oogie Boogie punch is inspired by the famous Nightmare Before Christmas. With a black marker, you can make marshmallows fun, Halloween decore for these fun drinks. Other than that, you just need green sherbet, lemon lime soda, and gummy bugs. You can whip these up in no time. 

18. Terrifying Halloween Punch: Blood Red Drinks

We’re keeping this punch straight up and simple. It doesn’t have to be complicated to be terrifying! Spider ice cubes make it freaky and perfect for a spooky party. Vodka, sparkling water, and cranberry-raspberry juice whill have you sipping on these spiders all night long. You can even get fancy and add fresh berries to add to the color and decor. 

19. Zombie Bash Virgin Drink

As I said before, we’re ranging from alcoholic to non-alcoholic to make sure everyone is included without sacrificing fun and flavor. These zombie bash drinks are perfect for adults or kids, and they are made of Hawaiian fruit punch, apple juice, cranberry juice, and ginger ale. The glittery red food coloring gives it that zombie bash touch needed. 

20. Wicked Worm Punch

This wicked worm punch comes to us from the famous Tipsy Bartender. I don’t know if you’ve seen him, but I love this sink-filling concoctions. This recipe is no exception. It’s a beautiful orange color that fogs from the top – perfect for any Halloween party. And he’s amazing with flavors too, so you know this won’t disappoint. 

21. Spider Cider Cocktail

Probably the only spider drink on this list that I would drink (I’m terrified of spiders) – this one is cute with the sprinkle decore around the edges. Even the little plastic spider wouldn’t scare me away. Apple cider, spiced rum, cherry extract, and a bit of old-fashioned caramel dip will make a drink that all guests will love.  

Whether you dig right into spooky season, or you’re wary of it, these terrifying Halloween punch recipes will not disappoint. You and your guests will get all the frightening feelings along with all of the delicious flavors from any of these drinks. Grab your broomsticks and get to the kitchen!

You May Also Like

About Meag

Health and Wellness Writer. B.S. Dietetics. Le Cordon Bleu Graduate. 10+ years of experience in the fitness and nutrition industry!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *