Fast food menus can be overwhelming, but the best tips often come from the people making your meal. At Arby’s, employees are taking to TikTok, Instagram, and Reddit to spill the beans on their personal favorites. From underrated classics to surprising sides, these insider picks cut through the noise and tell you what’s actually worth your money. Some items have loyal fan bases, while others are quiet sleepers you’ve probably skipped. Here’s the real scoop on what Arby’s workers swear by when they’re not behind the counter.
Ham & Swiss Melt Is the Sleeper Hit
Employees rave about this simple sandwich, even though customers rarely order it. Thinly sliced ham, melty Swiss cheese, and a sesame seed bun make it a comfort classic. Workers call it “incredibly underrated” and even say it might be the best sandwich Arby’s has ever sold. If you’re looking for a hidden gem, this is the one you should try.
Smokehouse Brisket Surprises Everyone
Brisket at a fast-food chain might raise eyebrows, but Arby’s version has die-hard fans. Smoked for 13 hours, it’s layered with smoked gouda, crispy onions, BBQ sauce, and mayo. Employees don’t just like it—they call it one of the best fast-food sandwiches out there. If you want smoky, savory, and bold, this one delivers.
Mozzarella Sticks With a Twist
Don’t overlook the sides—especially the mozzarella sticks. One employee revealed their favorite hack: ditching the marinara and dipping them in Bronco Berry sauce instead. The combo of gooey cheese and sweet-spicy sauce has TikTok buzzing. It’s proof that sometimes the sides steal the show.
Classic Beef ‘N Cheddar Never Misses
When asked to share their top pick, many workers still point to this icon. Stacked with roast beef and cheddar on an onion roll, it’s the definition of Arby’s comfort food. It’s the one sandwich that never seems to fall out of favor. If you’re new to Arby’s, this is the safe—and tasty—bet.
Potato Cakes Make a Quiet Comeback
Fries might be the default, but insiders say potato cakes are the real star. Crispy, golden, and hash brown-like, they recently returned to some menus. Employees admit they even prefer them over the fries. If you spot them at your local Arby’s, grab them while you can.
Greek Gyro Brings Bold Flavors
This isn’t your average fast-food wrap. Made with seasoned gyro meat, onions, tomatoes, and tangy gyro sauce on warm pita bread, it’s a worker-approved favorite. Some also love swapping in roast beef for a twist. Even ranch skeptics are fans when paired with Arby’s parmesan peppercorn ranch.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Returns to Fame
After disappearing from the menu a few times, this sandwich is back and beloved. It layers breaded chicken with smoked ham, melted Swiss, and mayo on a brioche bun. Employees say they’re thrilled to see it return, calling it one of their must-order items. For fans of hearty, indulgent sandwiches, this one hits the spot.
What’s Your Arby’s Go-To?
Arby’s employees aren’t shy about sharing what they actually eat on their breaks, and their choices show the menu is deeper than just roast beef. From cheesy sides to underrated sandwiches, these picks prove that the real treasures might be the items you’ve been overlooking. Have you tried any of these insider favorites? Drop a comment and let us know which one deserves the crown at your local Arby’s.
